It started with The Sound of Music. Over and over in my life, I had "You've never seen The Sound of Music?!?!?" squealed at me in such a way that nearby non-English speakers might well have guessed that I had just confessed to inveterate cannibalism. After a while, I started to think about why I was being scolded so harshly for my non-compliance with a clause of the social contract I clearly hadn't read.
And that brought me to the idea of Need-to-Know Movies. You know what these are. Indeed, the very fact of their essential nature should make any explanation unnecessary. But I'll explain anyway.
These are the films that everyone expects everyone else to be instantly familiar with. If someone makes a joking allusion to such a movie, they don't need to explicitly identify the source. The Office sometimes plays on this idea by having Michael make an obvious reference to one of these films, then wait a beat and unnecessarily name the movie, thus intensifying the lameness of his joke.
If someone comes to a costume party dressed as a character from one of these films, everyone will instantly recognize who they're supposed to be. If someone describes a real-life situation by saying, "This is just like [title of movie]," everyone understands why that movie is being invoked. If someone uses the name of the film as shorthand for a character type, place, behavior, etc., everyone unblinkingly processes it.
These movies are cultural touchstones. There's some element of them that resonates, whether it's a line, a scene, a character, or a general idea. As my Sound of Music experience shows, they're the kind of movies that you take for granted to the point that you're surprised if other people aren't familiar with them. They seem like such a part of the fabric of our culture that they feel eternal and unavoidable.
Of course, every person is their own culture in a way, and will therefore have their own touchstones. There will obviously also be local cultures (a family, a subculture, etc.) in which certain films will be seen as essential that aren't as important to the wider culture. What I'm trying to get at here are the movies that are either clearly relevant to that wider culture or so important to a particular segment that the wider culture is aware of them.
So I started making a list and bringing up that list in conversation, which made it change and grow. Eventually it got close to 200 movies, and I arbitrarily decided that I should limit it to that number. It's probably close to the number of films that the general public can keep in its collective mind at one time anyway.
Keep in mind that what is culturally relevant will constantly change, so a film that was unequivocally crucial a generation ago might have outlived its relevance by today. And today's essential movies might fall away in turn. What I'm trying to capture here is a snapshot of today's movies.
It's also important to note that these aren't necessarily good films. What I'm considering here is how culturally relevant they are, not how much I, you, or film critics like or appreciate them. But I feel like I'm starting to sound defensive before I've put out anything to defend, so here's the list as it stands right now. Let the arguments begin.
2001: A Space Odyssey [the theme, the opening section with the prehumans, HAL...]
9 to 5 [helped by the song, but just clinging onto relevance]
A Christmas Story [fra-gi-le]
A Clockwork Orange [the look, the slang, the ultraviolence]
A Few Good Men [a line we all know]
A Nightmare on Elm Street (any) [premise, character]
Ace Ventura: Pet Detective [like I said, the movie doesn't have to be good]
Airplane! [the standout representative of the spoof genre]
Alien or Aliens [the titular creatures, the bursting-out-of-the-stomach scene]
Animal House [the general atmosphere if nothing else]
Annie Hall [Woody Allen needs to be on the list somewhere]
Apocalypse Now [Vietnam, napalm, operatic helicopters, the horror]
Apollo 13 [a line we all know]
Austin Powers [the character and catchphrases]
Babe [talking animal and "That'll do, pig," but I find this one tenuous]
Back to School [the idea and Dangerfield together]
Back to the Future [the premise, the car, etc.]
Basic Instinct [the crossing of legs]
Batman [a few lines, the new-school superhero reboot, the overall look]
Beaches [general tearjerking]
Beverly Hills Cop [song, character]
Big [the premise, the piano scene]
Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure [characters, speech pattern, premise]
Billy Madison or Happy Gilmore [Sandler man-child persona]
Blade Runner [setting, androids/cyborgs]
Blazing Saddles [representative of parody genre/Mel Brooks films]
Blue Velvet [representative of David Lynch surrealist weirdness]
Borat [the character/voice]
Boyz in the Hood [inner city youths]
Braveheart [costumes, freedom speech]
Breakfast at Tiffany's [overall look]
Bridget Jones' Diary [character/archetype]
Brokeback Mountain [homosexuality, cowboys]
Bull Durham [some lines, sports/romcom blend]
Caddyshack [groundhog, screwball premise, golf setting]
Cape Fear [tattoos, premise, threatening stalker]
Carrie [blood scene, picked-on girl getting revenge]
Casablanca [lots of lines, song, etc.]
Cast Away [Wilson, premise]
Chinatown [losing its relevance, I think]
Citizen Kane [Rosebud, AFI's top film]
City Slickers [premise/setting]
Clash of the Titans (the original) [Greek mythological setting]
Close Encounters of the Third Kind [mashed potatoes, meeting the aliens scene]
Clueless [character/archetype]
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon [representative of the new-school martial arts genre]
Dead Poets Society [premise, "O Captain"]
Deliverance [banjo music, creepy mountainfolk]
Die Hard [premise, a line we all know]
Dirty Dancing [songs, a line we all know]
Do the Right Thing [racial tension]
Dr. Strangelove [Cold War setting, riding the bomb scene, etc.]
Dumb and Dumber [characters/archetypes]
E.T. [several scenes and lines, alien]
Fame [song, premise]
Fargo [accent, setting]
Fast Times at Ridgemont High [character, premise/setting]
Fatal Attraction [situation]
Father of the Bride [situation]
Ferris Bueller's Day Off [characters, premise, a few scenes]
Field of Dreams [a line we all know, premise]
Flashdance [music, scene we all know]
Footloose [song, premise]
Forrest Gump [premise, character, a line we all know]
Friday the 13th (any) [character, premise]
Full Metal Jacket [Vietnam, boot camp setting]
Ghost [a scene we all know]
Ghostbusters [song, premise]
Gone with the Wind [a line we all know, Civil War setting]
Good Morning, Vietnam [a line we all know]
Good Will Hunting [premise, a few lines/scenes]
Goodfellas [overall Scorsese/mobster vibe]
Grease [songs, setting]
Gremlins [characters, premise]
Groundhog Day [premise]
Guess Who's Coming to Dinner [premise]
Halloween [character, premise]
Harry Potter (any) [characters, premise]
Home Alone [a scene we all know, premise]
Hoosiers [sports premise]
Independence Day [White House scene, premise]
Indiana Jones (first 3) [character, premise]
It's a Wonderful Life [premise, some lines]
James Bond film (any, pref. Goldfinger) [character, premise]
Jaws [music, shark]
Jerry Maguire [a line we all know, premise]
Jurassic Park [premise]
King Kong [character, Empire State Building]
Lord of the Rings (any) [premise, characters]
Love Story [tearjerking premise, a line we all know]
Mary Poppins [songs, characters]
Men in Black [premise]
Miracle on 34th Street [Christmas, courtroom scene]
Mommie Dearest [a line we all know, archetypal abusive mother]
Monty Python and the Holy Grail [premise, some lines]
Moulin Rouge [style/look, songs]
Mr. Holland's Opus [premise]
Mr. Mom [premise]
Mr. Smith Goes to Washington [premise]
Mrs. Doubtfire [premise]
My Big Fat Greek Wedding [premise]
My Cousin Vinny [premise, "two youths"]
My Fair Lady [songs, premise]
Napoleon Dynamite [characters]
National Lampoon's Vacation [several scenes/lines, premise]
North by Northwest [plane scene, Mount Rushmore scene, general Hitchcockness]
Ocean's Eleven (new) [premise, Vegas]
Office Space [setting/premise, smashing office machines]
Old School [premise/setting, some lines]
Old Yeller [don't make me write it]
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest [characters, setting]
Parenthood [premise]
Pee-Wee's Big Adventure [character, some scenes/lines, Burton style]
Philadelphia [premise]
Pirates of the Caribbean (any) [characters, setting]
Planet of the Apes [scenes and lines we all know, premise]
Police Academy (any) [premise, characters]
Poltergeist [a line we all know, premise]
Predator [premise, Arnold]
Pretty Woman [premise, a few scenes]
Psycho [shower scene, music, premise]
Pulp Fiction [several scenes, violence]
Rain Man [some scenes/lines, premise]
Raising Arizona [song, premise]
Reality Bites [premise, overall Generation X vibe]
Rear Window [voyeurism premise]
Rebel Without a Cause [character/archetype]
Remember the Titans [inspirational sports premise]
Reservoir Dogs [violence, songs, ear scene]
Revenge of the Nerds [premise]
Risky Business [underwear scene]
Rocky (at least I and IV) [premise, underdog sports premise]
Roger & Me or Fahrenheit 9/11 [Michael Moore style]
Rudy [inspirational sports premise]
Saturday Night Fever [music, style]
Saving Private Ryan [premise/setting]
Saw (any) [premise, torture genre representative]
Scarface [several lines/scenes]
Schindler's List [premise/setting]
Scream [premise, mask]
Shrek (any) [characters]
Silence of the Lambs [a few lines/scenes, premise]
Singin' in the Rain [songs, title song scene]
Single White Female [situation]
Sixteen Candles [premise, John Hughesness]
Sleepless in Seattle [premise, Hanks and Ryan]
Slumdog Millionaire [premise, setting]
Sophie's Choice [situation]
Spartacus [setting, "I'm Spartacus" scene]
Speed [premise]
Stand By Me [flashback childhood premise]
Star Trek (any) [tenuous, since its relevance is significantly influenced by the TV show]
Star Wars (Episodes IV-VI) [needs no explanation]
Steel Magnolias [strong Southern woman archetype]
Superman (I or II) [characters, a few scenes]
Taxi Driver [premise, a scene/line we all know]
The Big Lebowski [characters, setting/feel]
The Blues Brothers [music, premise, characters]
The Breakfast Club [premise, characters, song]
The Crying Game [premise]
The Dark Knight [characters]
The Deer Hunter [premise, a few scenes]
The Exorcist [premise, a few scenes]
The Godfather (I and II) [needs no explanation]
The Goonies [youth premise, Sloth]
The Graduate [scenes/lines we all know, music]
The Great Escape [premise, song]
The Hangover [Vegas attachment, premise]
The Karate Kid [scenes we all know, premise]
The Lion King [songs, premise]
The Little Mermaid [songs, characters, premise]
The Matrix [premise, style]
The Natural [sports premise, lights scene]
The Notebook [premise, "chick flick" power]
The Princess Bride [lines/characters]
The Rocky Horror Picture Show [cult status, style]
The Shawshank Redemption [premise/setting]
The Shining [setting, lines/scenes we all know]
The Sixth Sense [a line we all know, premise]
The Sound of Music [songs, premise]
The Terminator (1 and 2) [characters, premise, a line we all know]
The Truman Show [premise]
The Usual Suspects [premise]
The Wizard of Oz [songs, premise, scenes/lines we all know]
Thelma and Louise [premise, ending scene]
There's Something About Mary [representative of the gross-out comedy genre]
This Is Spinal Tap [representative of the mockumentary genre, a few lines]
Three Men and a Baby [situation/premise]
Titanic [needs no explanation]
Tootsie [premise]
Top Gun [premise, character, some scenes/lines we all know]
Toy Story [representative of the new school animated genre]
Twilight [premise, characters]
Wall Street [premise, a line we all know]
WarGames [premise, a line we all know]
War of the Worlds (original) [premise]
West Side Story [songs, premise]
When Harry Met Sally [premise, a scene we all know]
Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory [songs, characters]
Who Framed Roger Rabbit? [animated/live action blend, characters]
Tin Cup in.
ReplyDeleteToy Story changed to Pixar films in general?
Clockwork orange, Encounters of Third Kind, Chinatown all losing relevance.
Stay strong. I too have yet to see "Sound of Music."
ReplyDeleteTin Cup doesn't have the mass recognition needed, and I almost never hear anyone outside of a golf context (which I am rarely in) refer to it.
ReplyDeleteI think Toy Story is iconic enough to stand on its own, but I don't disagree with putting a down arrow next to A Clockwork Orange, Close Encounters, and Chinatown. Maybe I should actually put down arrows on the list...
Too funny. Neighbor just sat me down to watch Sound of Music this summer for the first time. Loved it. &&& I knew all the songs. Go figure.
ReplyDeleteInteresting post. As you say, "Every person is their own culture in a way, and will therefore have their own touchstones." I started to work through my top 10 and only got up to the D's for indispensbale films before using up the allotment. Here, then, are my Top Ten Resonant Films Beginning with A, B, C, or D: A Clockwork Orange, Animal House, Annie Hall, Basic Instinct, Blue Velvet, Breakfast at Tiffany's, Brokeback Mountain, Casablanca, Chinatown, and Dr. Strangelove.
ReplyDeleteHi Wayne,
ReplyDeleteFascinating list...the only glaring omission, in terms of my "local" culture, is Naked Gun. This film defined the way in which we spoke to each other in High School. Would be interesting to accumulate lists from differing parts of the country. I wonder how many duplicates there would be between this list (which we largely share) and somebody (American born) from East Los Angeles, let's say. My wife and I completely talk past each other when discussing movies that we grew up with...she is from south Georgia and I am from your neck of the woods. For years, she thought it was just my accent when I would pronounce McDonald's as "McDowell's" (Coming to America)!
Cousin Kevin
I would make a case for Sleeping Beauty and Lion King, but there's only so much Disney you can put in there. I have to agree with the majority of the list - the titles are either movies I have seen over and over again, movies I want to revisit, or movies I have on my "watch later" list.
ReplyDeletePS - I would also make a case for Young Frankenstein or Men in Tights. Walk this way!
We could keep a running up and down trends on the list. Maybe have a "also received votes" list.
ReplyDeleteI think I'm going to knock Chinatown off the list and add Snow White. I'd appreciate more suggestions about movies on the bubble. That should start some fruitful discussion.
ReplyDeleteSpeaking as a vintage Baby Boomer - I know, who cares? - Snow White should definitely go on the list, and Bambi too. The death of Bambi's mother was one of the most traumatic events of my childhood.
ReplyDeleteBabe and Police Academy heading out.
ReplyDeleteComing to America?
Some Will Ferrell movie.
Coming to America was on an earlier version of the list, but some conversations showed that it was confined to too narrow a demographic.
ReplyDeleteWill Ferrell is in Old School, which is on the list. Anchorman is still too narrow, but could bloom later.
This film may be significant to my generation only, but I make a case for Cool Hand Luke.
ReplyDeleteWhat we have here...
Missing movies:
ReplyDeleteHarold & Maude...lots and lots of references to it these days...I think it was the bastard step-mother of Dawson's Creek.
Royal Tenenbaums or some other Wes Anderson film. He's the new Harold Ramis man. Embrace it.
Blair Witch Project. On the tail end of its cultural relevance but it still has legs. Especially with movies like Paranormal Activities.
The Ten Commandments. More relevant than Spartacus I think.
9 1/2 Weeks. Everyone should know this movie and it's the defining mainstream erotic Hollywood movie of all time.
JFK. No brainer. Put Oliver Stone on the map.
The Bodyguard. Soooo money.
At least one movie by Michael Moore has got to be on the list.
Movies that don't deserve to be on the list:
Who Framed Roger Rabbit? I can't think of a single time I've ever heard or seen of a reference to that.
Policy Academy. 80s are over.
Mary Poppins. Sure the character, books and musical are relevant but not convinced about the movie.
Parenthood. Meh.
Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure. Not convinced. The speech patterns were making fun of the valley...the movie didn't make it famous.
Singe White Female.
Back to School. Personally, love it. Fantastic. Culturally relevant? Not so sure.
I second Cool Hand Luke, and I can eat 50 eggs.
ReplyDeleteLots to respond to. Here goes:
ReplyDeleteCool Hand Luke: The line we all know is fading in popularity, and even those who still use it or hear it often have no idea where it comes from.
Harold & Maude: While its proponents love it, a majority of Americans have never heard of it.
Wes Anderson: A certain segment of America can't imagine culture without him, but many people have no idea who he is or what his movies are. Also, he doesn't have one singular signature film that everyone references.
Blair Witch: I think this has a good case, though I agree it is fading as it's replaced by derivatives.
The Ten Commandments: I feel like the iconic images of this film are (to use an imperfect word) poisoned by prior knowledge of the story. Did this film make Moses and the ten commandments famous? No.
9 1/2 Weeks: A case can be made for this as the gold standard for steaminess in film. On the other hand, it's aging poorly.
JFK: I hope "no brainer" was a tasteless joke, but in any case I can't disagree more about this movie's relevance. People might refer to the actual assassination or to Oliver Stone, but not so much this film.
The Bodyguard: The song definitely helps. I'd consider this one.
Michael Moore: Read the list more carefully--he's on there.
Roger Rabbit: I think you're right, Brandon. It's hard to justify the historical technical importance after Avatar. The only thing mitigating is the odd persistence of the Jessica Rabbit image in our culture.
Police Academy: I agree that it gets a down arrow, and might have fallen below the Mendoza line.
Mary Poppins: You're just misguided about this one. The movie dominates the other forms.
Parenthood: I agree on this one as well. It has outlived its usefulness, as indicated by the TV version arising.
Bill & Ted: I could go either way on this movie. Clearly the speech pattern was popularized elsewhere, but this film became powerfully symbolic of it. And the time travel aspect helps.
Single White Female: In the few days since I posted this list, I've heard three separate sources allude to SWF behavior. The movie title is shorthand for creepy imitation and psychotic roommate situations.
Back to School: Perhaps my sense of its importance is skewed by the fact that I haven't seen it, since whenever I hear it alluded to I feel left out.
This is the kind of discussion I was hoping for. Thanks, everyone. Let's keep it going.
Cool Hand Luke: The line we all know is fading in popularity, and even those who still use it or hear it often have no idea where it comes from
ReplyDeletePrecisely why this is iconic - part of popular culture, it reaches across generations!
Wayne,Ken says the problem is that what we have here is a failure to communicate.
Back to School is a very funny movie!
Could it be that there are no true traditional cowboy movies on this list? (Blazing Saddles doesn't really count). What does that say about how important that genre was? Not very. I still think that "Quiet Man" should make the list but I think I'm still the only vote on that. And Will Feral (yes, yes, I know) should be locked in a small room and forced to watch his movies over and over again. My personal dealbreaker.
ReplyDeleteI agree with Rick that Quiet Man is an unforgettable movie. The missing western brings to mind two movies, The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly (probably not a western in the true sense) and FIstful of Dollars.
ReplyDeleteThe lack of Westerns isn't surprising to me, since it's a genre that has become increasingly less relevant to our culture over the last 40 years. If you want to see how far it has fallen, ask one of my students a few questions about Westerns. Odds are good you'll get nothing but blank expressions.
ReplyDeleteAs for The Quiet Man, few people my age or younger have even heard of it. And I'm not that young.
And now begins the downward spiral of commenting on the comments of a comment. This is usually where I drop out of internet discussions.
ReplyDeleteSingle White Female - Can you say confirmation bias?
Harold & Maude - If the basis is that a majority of Americans have seen it, you'd have to drop half of the movies on the list. I thought the question was about it's impact on pop culture...in which case, it's ardent supporters happen to be a lot of people who influence and are employed in pop culture. It's influence persists.
JFK - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gcaq4ElAJrE
9 1/2 Weeks - Aging poorly? That's crazy talk.
Given your comment about Harold & Maude, I think I might just have misunderstood the rankings. I think might answer was more of a which films have influenced pop culture...now which films have most Americans seen and would be most likely to identify scenes or quotes from. If that's the case, I think its less interesting and needs to include things like You've Got Mail, every single one of Adam Sandler movies, etc.
To add another layer, Inception-style, to the commentary:
ReplyDeleteBrandon, I think you're right that it would be interesting to do a cultural impact list as well. There would be some overlap with this cultural relevancy list, of course, but there would also be a lot of interesting new paths to follow. It would be more subjective, I imagine, but there's nothing wrong with that.
I assume that by Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, you mean Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. While the former (2005, starring Johnny Depp) shares the title of the original novel, there's no way it eclipses its forebear (1971, starring Gene Wilder) in any kind of cultural relevance. Not yet, anyway.
ReplyDeleteHow about Unforgiven - the greatest cowboy movie and pretty much the last cowboy movie?
ReplyDeleteThanks for the correction on Willy Wonka, Rob--it has been fixed.
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry, but as I see it Unforgiven just doesn't ever come up in everyday life, and putting it on here would just be cowboy tokenism. I know some people will find it hard to accept, but the Western genre just doesn't mean much to America as a whole these days. I think we can have a good discussion about what has replaced it, but no single Western movie seems to resonate now.
I agree with Jan that The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly is worthy of consideration, if only for Ennio Morricone's landmark score. I defy anyone not to recognize it.
ReplyDeleteWhat about the Lethal Weapon trilogy? (I refuse to acknowledge that #4 happened.)
ReplyDeleteGreat pop culture references, (diplomatic immunity!, im too old for this @#$%^!)
And Mel Gibson before he went crazy and made What Women Want.