Relevant elements: Scarlett and Rhett, Tara, Civil War setting, making a dress out of curtains, "I don't know nothing about birthing babies," "Frankly, my dear..."
Why it resonated: The film took a wildly popular novel and applied the state of the art of filmmaking to adapting it, so it's no surprise that this became an instant classic.
General comments on the film: Several things have kept me from viewing this film until now: its four-hour runtime, my allergy to romantic visions of the Old South, a feeling that I was already familiar with the important parts of it, and so on. The only thing motivating me to watch it was guilt about skipping one of the pillars of film history, and that wasn't enough to overcome the list of cons.
Now that I've seen it, I can say that the things that made me avoid it for so long were certainly present in the film, but I was surprised in both positive and negative ways by other elements. Let me get the negatives out of the way. Even though it's a period piece, the film's gratuitous references to the antebellum code of gentility (riding in buggies in the afternoon without a chaperon is scandalous, young ladies take naps at parties, etc.) start to grate after a while, but not nearly as much as the general shrillness of the movie. And I'm not just talking about Prissy, although I quickly began to wish the collector's edition I was watching were a special version that automatically muted all of her lines. A full half of the characters seem to speak only in melodramatic shrieks and squawks, which I blame partly on the conventions of acting at the time but still find nerve-rattling.
On the other hand, it was fun to see the scale of the film's technical ambition, even when its process shots didn't quite succeed. Though it was used to the point that a third of the movie felt like it was shot in silhouette, some of the shadows-against-an-orange-sky shots were exquisite in terms of creating the perfect atmosphere. And that's to say nothing of justly famous passages like the slow crane pullback to reveal hundreds of Confederate wounded (and nearly as many obvious dummies). Despite being overstuffed with soap opera beats, especially in its last third, the film left me impressed with its ability to maintain a compelling story for such a long time, especially when compared to some of today's hit movies that gasp across the 86-minute finish line. This is a film that announces its grandeur right from the start and never lets you forget just how big it is, but while that often drags a movie down or turns it into a parody, somehow Gone with the Wind manages to bear up under its own weight, and that is no small accomplishment.
No comments:
Post a Comment